When I work with clients looking for indexed universal life insurance, one of the first questions they ask is, “Which companies should I consider?” It’s a smart question – not all IUL carriers are created equal, and the company you choose can significantly impact your policy’s performance and your family’s financial future.
For a complete overview, see how final expense insurance works.
After years of helping families navigate this decision, I’ve learned that the best indexed universal life companies share certain characteristics: strong financial ratings, competitive crediting rates, flexible policy features, and a track record of treating policyholders fairly. Let me walk you through what makes an IUL company worth considering and highlight some of the top performers in today’s market.
What Makes an IUL Company “The Best”?
Before diving into specific companies, it’s important to understand what separates excellent IUL carriers from mediocre ones. When I evaluate companies for my clients, I look at several key factors.
Financial Strength Ratings
This is non-negotiable. You’re making a long-term commitment with your IUL policy, potentially for decades. The insurance company needs to be financially stable enough to honor its commitments throughout that entire period.
I only recommend companies with strong ratings from independent agencies:
- A.M. Best: A- (Excellent) or higher
- S&P Global: A- or higher
- Moody’s: A3 or higher
- Fitch: A- or higher
A company might have great policy features, but if they’re not financially sound, those features won’t matter if the company struggles down the road.
Index Options and Crediting Methods
The whole point of indexed universal life is to potentially earn higher returns than traditional universal life while maintaining downside protection. The best companies offer:
- Multiple index options (S&P 500, NASDAQ, Russell 2000, etc.)
- Competitive participation rates and caps
- Various crediting methods (annual point-to-point, monthly averaging, etc.)
- Flexibility to allocate between different strategies
Policy Flexibility
Life changes, and your insurance policy should be able to adapt. Top-tier companies offer features like:
- Flexible premium payments
- Adjustable death benefits
- Multiple rider options
- Loan provisions that don’t disrupt index crediting
Claims Paying History
How a company handles claims tells you everything about their character. The best companies have a reputation for paying valid claims promptly and fairly, without unnecessary delays or disputes.
Top Indexed Universal Life Companies to Consider
Based on my experience working with these carriers, here are companies that consistently deliver strong value for IUL policyholders:
Pacific Life
Pacific Life has been a standout in the IUL market with their strong financial ratings and innovative policy designs. They offer:
Strengths:
- A+ (Superior) rating from A.M. Best
- Competitive index options with attractive caps
- Strong loan provisions
- Excellent customer service reputation
Considerations:
- Premium pricing varies by age and health
- Some products have higher minimum premiums
AIG (American General)
AIG brings over a century of experience to the life insurance market, with particularly strong IUL offerings.
Strengths:
- A (Excellent) rating from A.M. Best
- Multiple index strategies available
- Flexible premium structure
- Good track record of competitive crediting rates
Considerations:
- Underwriting can be more stringent than some competitors
- Policy illustrations should be reviewed carefully
Lincoln Financial
Lincoln has made significant investments in their IUL platform and offers some compelling features.
Strengths:
- A+ (Superior) rating from A.M. Best
- Innovative index strategies
- Strong financial performance history
- Competitive loan rates
Considerations:
- Product complexity requires careful explanation
- May not be the most cost-effective for smaller face amounts
Transamerica
Transamerica has built a solid reputation in the IUL space with competitive products and strong financial backing.
Strengths:
- A (Excellent) rating from A.M. Best
- Multiple index options
- Flexible policy design
- Good customer service
Considerations:
- Caps and participation rates can vary
- Important to compare current assumptions
Prudential
As one of the largest life insurers in the US, Prudential brings stability and resources to their IUL offerings.
Strengths:
- A+ (Superior) rating from A.M. Best
- Strong financial resources
- Established track record
- Multiple product options
Considerations:
- May have higher internal costs than some competitors
- Underwriting process can be lengthy
How to Choose the Right Company for Your Situation
Here’s the reality: there’s no single “best” indexed universal life company for everyone. The right choice depends on your specific situation, goals, and priorities.
Consider Your Age and Health
Some companies are more competitive for younger, healthier applicants, while others might offer better rates for older applicants or those with minor health issues. For example, if you have well-controlled diabetes, one carrier might offer you standard rates while another might add a table rating.
Evaluate Your Premium Budget
Companies structure their pricing differently. Some front-load costs but offer lower ongoing expenses, while others spread costs more evenly. Depending on how you plan to fund your policy, one approach might work better than another.
Think About Your Long-Term Goals
Are you primarily focused on death benefit protection, cash accumulation, or a combination? Some companies design their products to excel in one area over others.
Review Current Assumptions
Insurance companies regularly adjust their assumptions about future performance. What looks competitive today might not be tomorrow. It’s important to work with someone who stays current on these changes.
Red Flags to Avoid
Not every company offering IUL is worth considering. Watch out for:
Poor Financial Ratings
Any company rated below A- from major rating agencies should be avoided, regardless of how attractive their policy features might seem.
Overly Aggressive Illustrations
If a company’s projections seem too good to be true compared to competitors, they probably are. Sustainable, realistic assumptions are more valuable than flashy projections.
Limited Track Record
Brand new entrants to the IUL market might offer attractive features, but they lack the track record to demonstrate how they’ll perform over time.
Poor Customer Service Reputation
You’ll potentially have this relationship for decades. Companies with poor service records or difficult claims processes should be avoided.
The Importance of Working with the Right Agent
Here’s something many people don’t realize: the agent you work with can be just as important as the company you choose. A knowledgeable agent who understands IUL design can help you:
- Compare multiple carriers objectively
- Structure your policy for optimal performance
- Understand the trade-offs between different features
- Navigate underwriting challenges
- Provide ongoing service throughout the life of your policy
When I work with clients, I don’t represent just one company – I have access to multiple top-rated carriers. This means I can shop your case to find the best combination of pricing, features, and underwriting treatment for your specific situation.
Questions to Ask Before You Buy
Before committing to any IUL policy, make sure you understand:
What are the current cap rates and participation rates? These can change over time.
What are the policy’s internal expenses? Lower expenses mean more of your premium goes toward cash value.
How flexible are the premium payments? Can you skip payments if needed?
What loan options are available? Some loan features can significantly impact performance.
What happens if you want to make changes later? How much flexibility do you have?
What’s the company’s history of treating policyholders during economic downturns? This tells you about their character.
Making Your Decision
Choosing among the best indexed universal life companies doesn’t have to be overwhelming. The key is working with someone who can evaluate your specific needs and match them with the right carrier and product.
In my experience, the “best” company is often the one that offers the right combination of financial strength, competitive features, and fair pricing for your particular situation. It’s not always the company with the flashiest marketing or the highest projected returns – it’s the one that will serve you well for the long term.
Remember, this is a long-term financial commitment. Take the time to understand your options, ask questions, and work with someone who can guide you through the process objectively.
The companies I’ve mentioned here represent some of the strongest options in today’s market, but there are other quality carriers worth considering depending on your circumstances. The key is making sure whoever you work with has access to multiple options and the expertise to help you make an informed decision.
Finding the right life insurance doesn’t have to be complicated. As an independent agent, I work with multiple top-rated carriers and can help you compare options to find the best coverage at the best price.
Related Reading
- Guaranteed Issue Final Expense Insurance: Your Complete Guide
- Funeral Insurance for Seniors: Your Complete Guide
- Burial Insurance for Seniors Over 80: Your Complete Guide
- Burial Insurance for Seniors Over 70: Your Complete Guide
Let me do the shopping for you. I’ll compare quotes from multiple companies and help you find coverage that fits your needs and budget, including access to some of the best indexed universal life companies in the market today.
- Compare multiple IUL companies before making a decision, as carriers vary significantly in financial stability, policy features, and long-term performance that will impact your family for decades.
- Focus on companies with strong A.M. Best ratings of A- or higher, as financial strength matters more than flashy marketing promises when you’re making a multi-decade commitment.
- Evaluate index options and crediting methods carefully, looking for carriers that offer multiple index choices, competitive participation rates and caps, and various crediting strategies.
- Prioritize policy flexibility features like adjustable premiums and death benefits, multiple rider options, and loan provisions that won’t disrupt your index crediting.
- Bring existing Lincoln Financial quotes to an independent agent for review, as they can help you compare options and ensure you’re getting the best value without being tied to a single carrier.
