When I sit down with someone who’s asking whether annuities are a good strategy for their financial future, I can see the confusion in their eyes. The financial world has painted annuities as both the savior of retirement and a complete scam—sometimes in the same conversation. After years of helping families navigate these waters, I’ve learned that the answer isn’t simple, but it’s not impossible to understand either.
For a complete overview, see learn more about annuities.
The truth is, is annuity good investment depends entirely on your specific situation, your goals, and—most importantly—what type of annuity we’re talking about. Not all annuities are created equal, and the industry hasn’t done itself any favors with confusing terminology and overly complex products.
Let me walk you through what I’ve learned about annuities over the years, the good and the bad, so you can make an informed decision about whether they belong in your financial strategy.
What Annuities Actually Are (And Why People Get Confused)
Think of an annuity as a contract with an insurance company. You give them money now, and they promise to give you money back later—usually as a stream of payments over time. It’s essentially the opposite of life insurance: instead of protecting against dying too soon, annuities protect against living too long and running out of money.
But here’s where it gets tricky: there are several different types of annuities, and they work very differently from each other:
Fixed Annuities
These offer guaranteed returns—currently around 3-5% annually. Your principal is protected, and you know exactly what you’ll get. Think of them like a CD with an insurance company instead of a bank.
Variable Annuities
These tie your returns to mutual fund-like investments. You can make more money when markets do well, but you can also lose money when they don’t. They come with higher fees and more complexity.
Indexed Annuities
These split the difference—your returns are tied to a market index like the S&P 500, but you have a floor (usually 0%) that protects against losses. You get some upside potential with downside protection.
Immediate Annuities
You hand over a lump sum and start receiving payments right away. These are pure income tools—you’re essentially buying a personal pension.
The Real Benefits of Annuities
When people ask me about annuities, I always start with the legitimate benefits, because there are some real advantages in the right situations:
Guaranteed Income Stream
This is the big one. If you’re worried about outliving your money, certain types of annuities can provide guaranteed income for life. In a world where pensions are disappearing and Social Security’s future is uncertain, that guarantee has value.
Principal Protection
With fixed and indexed annuities, your principal is protected from market downturns. You might not make much, but you won’t lose what you put in (assuming you hold to maturity and the insurance company remains solvent).
Tax-Deferred Growth
Money grows inside an annuity without being taxed each year, similar to a 401k or IRA. You only pay taxes when you take money out.
No Contribution Limits
Unlike retirement accounts, there’s no limit to how much you can put into an annuity. If you’ve maxed out your 401k and IRA and still want tax-deferred growth, annuities are one of the few options.
The Problems With Annuities (And Why Critics Have Valid Points)
Now let’s talk about why annuities have such a bad reputation in some circles. The critics aren’t wrong about everything:
High Fees and Commissions
Variable annuities especially can have fees that add up to 2-3% annually or more. Those fees compound over time and can seriously eat into your returns. Insurance agents often receive large upfront commissions, which creates an incentive to sell whether it’s right for you or not.
Complexity and Fine Print
Many annuity contracts are incredibly complex, with riders, caps, participation rates, and surrender charges that can be difficult to understand. I’ve seen too many people sign contracts they didn’t fully comprehend.
Liquidity Restrictions
Most annuities have surrender periods—sometimes 7-10 years—where you’ll pay penalties for withdrawing your money. If you need access to your funds, you could be stuck.
Inflation Risk
Fixed annuities might protect your principal, but they often don’t keep up with inflation over time. A guaranteed 4% return doesn’t look so good if inflation is running at 6%.
When Annuities Make Sense (And When They Don’t)
In my experience, annuities can make sense in specific situations:
Annuities might be right for you if:
- You’re within 10 years of retirement and want guaranteed income
- You’ve maximized other tax-advantaged accounts
- You have a lump sum (inheritance, settlement, etc.) and want principal protection
- You’re extremely risk-averse and value guarantees over growth potential
- You don’t have a pension and want to create your own
Annuities probably aren’t right if:
- You’re young and have a long time horizon (growth potential is more important)
- You haven’t maximized your 401k and IRA contributions
- You need liquidity and access to your money
- You’re comfortable managing your own portfolio
- You’re looking for maximum growth potential
The Annuity vs. Other Strategies Question
Here’s where I try to give people perspective. When someone asks me if annuities are a good strategy, I always ask: “Compared to what?”
If you’re comparing a fixed annuity to keeping money in a savings account earning 0.5%, the annuity probably wins. But if you’re comparing it to a diversified portfolio over a 20-year time horizon, the math usually favors the portfolio.
The real question isn’t whether annuities are good or bad—it’s whether they’re the right tool for your specific situation and goals.
What to Look Out For If You’re Considering An Annuity
If you decide an annuity might be right for you, here are the key things I tell people to watch out for:
Understand All the Fees
Ask for a complete breakdown of all costs—management fees, rider fees, mortality and expense charges, and surrender charges. Add them all up to see the total annual cost.
Read the Surrender Schedule
Know exactly how long your money will be tied up and what penalties you’ll face for early withdrawal. Most annuities allow some annual withdrawals (usually 10%) without penalty.
Understand the Caps and Participation Rates
With indexed annuities, you won’t get the full index return. There are caps (maximum you can earn) and participation rates (what percentage of the index gain you receive). Make sure you understand these limitations.
Know the Insurance Company’s Rating
Your annuity is only as good as the insurance company backing it. Stick with companies rated A- or better by rating agencies like A.M. Best, Moody’s, or S&P.
My Honest Take on Annuities
After years in this business, here’s my honest assessment: annuities are neither the miracle solution some salespeople claim nor the scam that some critics suggest. They’re financial tools with specific uses and specific drawbacks.
For the right person in the right situation, an annuity can provide valuable guarantees and peace of mind. For someone else, those same guarantees might come at the cost of growth potential they need for their long-term goals.
The key is understanding what you’re getting, what you’re giving up, and whether the trade-off makes sense for your specific situation.
I’ve seen annuities work well for people who needed guaranteed income and couldn’t sleep at night worrying about market volatility. I’ve also seen them be completely wrong for people who bought them because of a high-pressure sales pitch without understanding the restrictions and fees.
- Understand that annuities are contracts with insurance companies where you pay money now for guaranteed income payments later, essentially protecting against outliving your retirement savings.
- Choose the right type based on your risk tolerance: fixed annuities offer guaranteed returns with principal protection, while variable annuities carry market risk but higher potential returns.
- Consider annuities primarily for guaranteed lifetime income if you’re concerned about running out of money in retirement, especially as pensions disappear and Social Security faces uncertainty.
- Evaluate whether principal protection matters to you, since fixed and indexed annuities protect your initial investment from market downturns unlike other investment options.
- Remember that annuities offer tax-deferred growth with no contribution limits, making them useful if you’ve maxed out other retirement accounts and want additional tax-advantaged savings.
The Bottom Line on Whether Annuities Are Good Strategies
So, is annuity good investment? Here’s my bottom line: annuities can be valuable tools for the right person, but they’re not suitable for everyone, and they shouldn’t be your only financial strategy.
Before considering an annuity, make sure you’ve:
- Maximized employer 401k matching
- Contributed to tax-advantaged accounts like IRAs
- Built an emergency fund
- Considered other income-generating strategies
If you’ve done all that and you still need guaranteed income or principal protection, then certain types of annuities might make sense as part of a broader financial strategy.
The most important thing is to work with someone who will look at your complete financial picture and recommend what’s truly best for your situation—not just what pays the highest commission.
Looking for honest guidance on whether an annuity fits your financial strategy? I work with multiple insurance companies and can help you explore all your options without the high-pressure sales tactics. Contact me for a consultation and let’s have an honest conversation about what makes sense for your specific situation.
